“[I]t’s impossible to separate character from plot from setting. The body is the apparatus of plot. The body is what characters use to do things.”
Elizabeth McCracken, in A Long Game
Stephen D. Gibson
“[I]t’s impossible to separate character from plot from setting. The body is the apparatus of plot. The body is what characters use to do things.”
Elizabeth McCracken, in A Long Game
Consider the first paragraph of The Heist by Janet Evanovich and Lee Goldberg:
Kate O’Hara’s favorite outfit was her blue windbreaker with the letters FBI written in yellow on the back, worn over a basic black T-shirt and matching black Kevlar vest. The ensemble went well with everything, particularly when paired with jeans and accessorized with a Glock. Thirty-three-year-old Special Agent O’Hare didn’t like feeling exposed and unarmed, especially on the job. That all but ruled her out for undercover work. Fine by her. She preferred a hard-charging style of law enforcement, which was exactly what she was practicing on that 96 degree winter afternoon in Las Vegas when she marched into the St. Cosmas Medical Center in her favorite outfit with a dozen similarly dressed agents behind her.
First sentences and first paragraphs should hook readers, should give them reasons to be interested in continuing to read. This paragraph begins with the name of a character, and that character is interesting in part because the language of two distinct worlds is brought together in her: fashion and policing. Specifically, this character has a favorite outfit of police gear, an “ensemble . . . accessorized with a Glock.” The first two sentences use two characterization techniques, appearance and employment, presented using clear visual images. In the third sentence, a restated name and job title provide a transition from the previous sentence; readers are given the character’s age, and they are given access to the character’s inner life. We know already something this character does not like. The fourth and fifth sentences continue to allow access to the character’s feelings and vary sentence lengths. The change in sentence lengths provides emphasis, and the emphasis itself characterizes: “Fine by her.” Continuing attention to the character’s inner life, “she preferred,” provides a transition from the fifth sentence to the last sentence of the paragraph. That last sentence shows the character acting, another way to characterize, and acting in a specific setting. The character’s action suggests an ongoing process. If readers are hooked by nothing else, they read on to discover the results of the process. Characters and readers finish the paragraph with momentum. In other words, by the end of the first paragraph, readers know journalism’s “Five Ws”: “who” is doing “what” “where.” They can estimate “when.” To discover “why,” they read on. (The “Five Ws” have their roots in Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics.) Finally, readers also know fairly specifically the genre they are reading.
Evanovich and Goldberg’s opening suggests several things we might try:
Similarly, Charlie Jane Anders wrote in Never Say You Can’t Survive, “I found that the more of a situation I could cram into those opening words, the greater the sense of momentum I could create, that could carry me through the rest of the story.” And also similarly, Elizabeth George in Write Away lists eight different hooks (page 70 in my edition) and many examples.
From The Land in Winter by Andrew Miller:
At the edge of the field, by the shadow-line of the hedge, a dog, or something like a dog, raised its head into the light, studied them a moment, the two women upright in the bareness of the field, then dropped out of sight again, soundlessly.
This sentence ends a chapter. The dog, or something like a dog, doesn’t reappear. It adds menace and tension to the novel, partly because of the situation (two pregnant women in a cold, snow-covered field), but also because of the word choices Miller has made: “Edge,” “shadow,” “into the light,” “studied,” “bareness,” “out of sight,” and “soundlessly,” for example. Most of all, the point of view allows readers to know something scary that the characters do not.
Two exercises, then. First, can we use the same words Miller does to create the opposite feeling for readers? We might allow ourselves to add words or see if we can change only their order. How are things different if the women watch the dog, for example? Second, how might we use the technique Miller uses? In other words, what can we let readers know that characters do not? How might this alarm readers, or how might it please them?
Consider these sentences from Hemlock and Silver by T. Kingfisher: “I thought long and hard about Isobel telling me to be tactful. But Isobel was what she was, and I was what I was, and if thirty-odd years and a lot of poison hadn’t changed that, I might as well embrace it. Tact is overrated anyway. And if I started being tactful now, he’d probably die of shock.” The italics are in the original.
I think decisions characterize, but in addition to their actions, what a character refuses to do can characterize them. Melville’s Bartleby is one example of this. In the paragraph above, the main character makes a decision and refuses to change. On one level, they reject their arc. On another, they remain true to themselves against social and familial pressure.
So, what will your character decide not to do? How might that put them at odds with larger social forces around them? In what ways might it encourage conformity? (See Frank Lentricchia’s Criticism and Social Change, pages 102-107 espeically, for more.)
In the introduction to the Best American Short Stories 2025 annual, Celeste Ng writes about skipping reading the introductions when she’s read the anthology in the past. Even more interesting, she describes the criteria for good fiction she discovered in the process of making her selections. These criteria can be aspirational; they might be expectations we set for ourselves. Excerpts are below. I’ve added numbers and altered paragraphing.
[1] First and foremost, the story had to grab me. Sometimes this meant an unforgettable premise, or a propulsive plot, or characters so fully drawn that I felt I would know them if I met them on the street. Sometimes it was charm, or humor, or an unexpected twist. The stories that ended up in the Yes pile were ones I couldn’t get out of my head, that I kept thinking about days or even weeks after reading them.
[2] Second, the story had to feel complete…. I wanted a sense that the writer had considered the story holistically, that every choice had been made deliberately, and that all the pieces fit together, even if the… [whole] picture wasn’t fully revealed. And by the time I reached the last line, I needed to understand something more about the situation than I did at the start…
[3] Third, the language of this story had to be of the very highest caliber. If a piece didn’t have sentences that startled or surprised me, or images that took my breath away with their absolute rightness, they usually didn’t make the cut….
[4] And finally … stories had to have heft … They didn’t have to be serious or sad… But I had to feel that this story and these characters were deeply important to the author, not just a thought experiment or a whim…. I also tend to gravitate towards stories that are in conversation with big topics, whether that means our current moment or broad-reaching and eternal themes…. The very best stories engage with more than just the purely personal, and this is what turns a good story into a great story.
| Title | Author | Date Read |
| The West Passage | Jared Pechaček | 2025/12/22 |
| Inherent Vice | Thomas Pynchon | 2025/12/19 |
| Under the Eye of the Big Bird | Hiromi Kawakami | 2025/11/29 |
| Emily Wilde’s Compendium of Lost Tales (Emily Wilde, #3) | Heather Fawcett | 2025/11/27 |
| Tuesday Mooney Talks to Ghosts | Kate Racculia | 2025/11/16 |
| The Wood at Midwinter | Susanna Clarke | 2025/10/27 |
| Swamplandia! | Karen Russell | 2025/10/26 |
| Wild Dark Shore | Charlotte McConaghy | 2025/10/17 |
| Tooth and Claw (A Longmire Mystery, #0.5) | Craig Johnson | 2025/10/07 |
| The Practice of Creative Writings: A Guide for Students | Heather Sellers | 2022/06/28 |
| The Tainted Cup (Shadow of the Leviathan, #1) | Robert Jackson Bennett | 2025/10/02 |
| Headshot | Rita Bullwinkel | 2025/09/27 |
| Emily Wilde’s Map of the Otherlands (Emily Wilde, #2) | Heather Fawcett | 2025/09/22 |
| Swords and Deviltry (Fafhrd and the Gray Mouser, #1) | Fritz Leiber | 2025/09/15 |
| Coriolis – The Third Horizon | Tomas Härenstam | 2025/09/13 |
| Someone You Can Build a Nest In | John Wiswell | 2025/09/12 |
| The Baltimore Book of the Dead | Marion Winik | 2025/08/25 |
| Remember You Will Die | Eden Robins | 2025/08/20 |
| Jack | Marilynne Robinson | 2025/08/14 |
| The Paper Magician (The Paper Magician #1) | Charlie N. Holmberg | 2025/07/26 |
| The Murder of Mr. Wickham (Mr. Darcy & Miss Tilney, #1) | Claudia Gray | 2025/07/20 |
| Love Your Enemies: How Decent People Can Save America from the Culture of Contempt | Arthur C. Brooks | 2025/07/17 |
| The Rose Metal Press Field Guide to Writing Flash Nonfiction | Dinty W. Moore | 2025/07/15 |
| Tenth of December | George Saunders | 2025/07/05 |
| At the Mouth of the River of Bees: Stories | Kij Johnson | 2025/06/30 |
| Everyone in My Family Has Killed Someone (Ernest Cunningham, #1) | Benjamin Stevenson | 2025/06/19 |
| A Wizard of Earthsea (Earthsea Cycle, #1) | Ursula K. Le Guin | 2025/06/09 |
| The Great Gatsby | F. Scott Fitzgerald | 2025/05/28 |
| The Department of Truth, Vol 1: The End of the World | James Tynion IV | 2025/05/17 |
| Bone: The Complete Edition | Jeff Smith | 2025/05/12 |
| Black Woods Blue Sky | Eowyn Ivey | 2025/05/08 |
| The Wonderful Wizard of Oz (Oz, #1) | L. Frank Baum | 2025/04/29 |
| City of Dancing Gargoyles | Tara Campbell | 2025/04/20 |
| The Daughter of Doctor Moreau | Silvia Moreno-Garcia | 2025/04/19 |
| Nine Goblins | T. Kingfisher | 2025/04/05 |
| Truth Is the Arrow, Mercy Is the Bow: A DIY Manual for the Construction of Stories | Steve Almond | 2025/04/04 |
| The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches | Sangu Mandanna | 2025/04/01 |
| Squirrel Meets World (The Unbeatable Squirrel Girl, #1) | Shannon Hale | 2025/03/27 |
| White Trash Warlock (Adam Binder, #1) | David R. Slayton | 2025/03/21 |
| The Sparrow (The Sparrow, #1) | Mary Doria Russell | 2025/03/13 |
| The Scandalous Confessions of Lydia Bennet, Witch | Melinda Taub | 2025/03/13 |
| The Dream-Quest of Vellitt Boe | Kij Johnson | 2025/02/24 |
| The God of the Woods | Liz Moore | 2025/02/19 |
| Pride and Prejudice | Jane Austen | 2025/02/12 |
| When the Women Come Out to Dance | Elmore Leonard | 2023/09/09 |
| Hyperion (Hyperion Cantos, #1) | Dan Simmons | 2025/02/01 |
| The Librarianist | Patrick deWitt | 2025/01/27 |
| 2312 | Kim Stanley Robinson | 2025/01/11 |
| The Last Emperox (The Interdependency, #3) | John Scalzi | 2025/01/03 |
“Portrait of the Artist as a Young Cephalopod Mollusk” has been published by The Ekphrastic Review.
Paraphrasing the hosts of the podcast Writing Excuses, someplace in season 19: When I say a narrative needs risk, it almost always needs a relationship. How does the failure affect the community around the character? People feel tension about things they can relate to, especially about things they can relate to being taken away from characters.
“Actors Burning Coffee in the Afternoon” has been published by The Citron Review.
Subscribe to get access to the rest of this post and other subscriber-only content.